The first time I sang as a vocal of a rock band was after I got into KMLA and became a member of PLZ, the school band. At first, I applied as a rock band vocal just because I liked singing. I didn’t have any experience of singing with a band or not even much experience of singing on a stage. I didn’t know much about rock. It was a whole new thing to me. I started to listen to new songs that I used not to know of and watch live videos of bands that I used not to have interest in. In the process, I learned that singing as a band vocal was different from just singing alone; it is like playing in a sports team. It is important that each one of us do well on our parts, but it is also important that we play in harmony as well. If we didn’t listen to each other’s sound, we wouldn’t play it well, even if we all did well on our parts. That was what I liked about singing in a band; I wasn’t just singing alone but singing ‘for’ the whole group.
Once there was a time when we were banned to perform because of the liability for food delivery to school. Many people ate delivered food, which was against the school law, at the third floor of Chungmu hall and left the trash there. The problem was that our practice studio was there. Teachers decided that we were responsible for not managing the third floor, and for the punishment, we were excluded from the list for the performance at the welcome party. Since it was true that we were those who used the place the most, we couldn’t resist the decision. At the party, we all felt depressed, and that was the time when I wanted to be on the stage most. Fortunately, on the party day, after all the performances were over, we were allowed to perform just one song, which became the stage that I will never forget. That was the time that I realized how meaningful PLZ was to me. Since then my life at KMLA cannot be explained without mentioning PLZ.
About a week from that, we performed in Rock Festival that took place in KMLA. That was the show that I enjoyed the most. When we sang ‘Happy Ending’, which was the favorite stage of mine, I felt different from what I did at the debut stage in Christmas party. As I had eye contact with every people under the stage, I felt like talking to each one of them. I really felt thankful to all of them, that they came to see our show, that they listened to our music, and that we could play for them. When I heard someone say that of all the stages that day, ‘Happy Ending’ was the most moving, I felt so proud of our members and myself. Maybe he could also hear me say ‘thank you’ to him as I sang the song.
I learned and felt many things as I played in PLZ for two years, about harmony, about working together with our members, and about being on stage. I have changed a lot, from a shy little girl who couldn’t even sing in front of her family and who quit learning piano because she was afraid of contests, to a school band vocal who freely expresses herself. I am still a shy person at times, but more of the time, I am an passionate, enthusiastic person, always active and alive.
I think there are wonderful ingredients here for a true college essay. Playing in a band can show your personality as a team player and leader. It can also illustrate how you "put yourself out there" and develop as a person. No longer shy. No longer afraid to take chances on center stage.
답글삭제Things I like:
1. You do present a clear them of testing yourself and developing. This is good, and something to hold on to.
2. The intro has some of the ingredients you need. A hook is there, and just needs to be polished.
3. You discuss good times and bad times with the band. There is a "journey" within the essay.
Things to improve:
1. The ingredients are there, but at this point is seems more like an outline discussing a potential essay. If you write it as a story, rather than an explanation, you will bring the entire thing to life with an active voice. Make it an engaging anecdote.
2. I think the start of the essay should be the food violation thing where you can't perform. Tell it in present tense first personal narrative. Show the dissapointment. Don't tell it.
3. The stuff you have in the first paragraph about being on stage might be best suited for the end of the essay. Kind of like the last scene in a film where the good guys win. You can dress that up with some Hyungseok-styled description.
All in all, the ideas are in place and the concepts and messages are ready. Just need to find the right vehicle to drive the story forward and make it more engaging. I think you'll get there after a couple of drafts.:)
Hi Ji Young!:)
답글삭제I think this is a good start! I really get what you are trying to say and who you are.
But there are things that need to be polished.
1. I think this is too much of telling than showing who you are. You say that you are a passionate person, which is not bad. However, it'll be better if the people reading your essay could "see" that you are passionate, than reading the exact words.
2. I think there are tons of essay topics in this essay. You can write an essay about "Happy Ending" and what it means to you. You can write about the incident when PLZ was blocked from performing at the party. Elaborate more:)
3. This is just my opinion, but maybe you could write about your ballet lessons? I always wanted to hear more about it..ㅎ_ㅎ
I love your writing style - it has all it has to have and does not get boring or dull. Keep up the good work!
I agree with Mr. Garrioch that you can write about the food violation incident as your intro. Show the readers how desperate you and your members were at that time, and show them how your passion and love towards PLZ were deepened.
답글삭제I like your story, since I was one of the people who really looked forward watching PLZ's performance in the welcoming party.
I still remember PLZ's performance-the one they gave after they had been forbidden to be on stage. It was impressive, touching, and overwhelming-like the climax of a movie scene. I really think that story has much potential for your essay. How about elaborating on it more: about your feelings, your realizations. I'd love to read that essay :)
답글삭제I think that you learned a lot from your experience as a rock band vocal. It is kind of interesting that rock band vocal is a difficult job. I thought what vocals had to do was just singing. This essay reveals some interesting aspects of who you are. However, I think that the essay as a whole isn't well organized enough to give the readers a strong message about who you truly are. I would recommend you narrow down into one or two experiences from which you learned the most. By doing so, you could present yourself effectively in the essay.
답글삭제PLZ is definitely a good essay topic for you I think. The whole story seems to reveal that PLZ means a lot to you. If I am to just point out some possible improvements, I can see you mingled the telling of the anecdote and the lessons you learned from with balance while writing, but I guess it is going to be valuable to try a different organization, like telling the anecdote first in the essay with more descriptions and then moving on to the elaboration of your thoughts and the lessons you've learned from it. I liked the essay overall for I can feel your genuine voice in it.
답글삭제It is clearly showing the point you want to see, the school rock band activity. It seems you have experienced many things through PLZ, so it would be great if you elaborate it focusing in one special story, and personally saying the banned performance episode looks good.
답글삭제Nice essay! I can't forget that moment when Mr Sung allowed you guys to give a performance. In this essay, you need a stronger hook in the intro paragraph. I think you know what you have to do since you already have a hook, but just make it more descriptive, exciting, and tense.
답글삭제Nice essay! It really reveals your love toward the band activity and singing.
답글삭제Things that might be improved? I think you need to explain more about certain KMLAian terms such as Chungmu hall just in case that people outside this school might not understand. Also, explaining more about why food delivery is such an issue would be good because people outside might be confused about it. Overall nice essay~!!
I like the topic, because it certainly seems to be one that describes you best. I also like that you derived a lesson a profound lesson about your life (cooperation) from PLZ, but I think that if you elaborate on this lesson more deeply, perhaps more theoretically, I think it could be improved.
답글삭제Also, be more descriptive about that dramatic moment at the freshmen welcome party! it was such a dramatic event (i remember that you cried, right? and so did other members of PLZ) that with a little more polishing, this will become a great source for a college essay.
답글삭제